Final presentation of project 5, excerpts from the poster presentation


 Main /  Curriculum /  Final pres. pt.1 /  pt.2 /  Pictures /  Handling SIRDO /  More about SIRDO

 
Click on image to enlarge.  

Find on this website:

Sustainable Wastewater Management

Composting toilets and processes

Sanitary aspects of compost toilets


Picture left shows Catherine Wakesho, participant of project 5, presenting results (Click on small image to enlarge).


Sustainable Wastewater Management

Pollution prevention
water minimization at source
through
REDUCE
of water or minimization
Decentra-
lized System
REUSE
for surface irrigation, ground water recharge, industrial processes, toilet flushing etc.
Centralized
System
    
Conservatory
technologies, wetlands, composting
toilets etc.
RECYCLE
of organic wastes, of water etc.
  

Conclusions

  • The selection of a sanitation technology has to take into account the economic, environmental and social-cultural conditions (psychology, religion and gender) of the community and have to involve its participation with a continuous approach from design to implementation. The community needs to be shown that there are alternatives that can work even better, than systems of the past.
  • Systems that require low cost technologies for wastewater treatment are feasible alternative to be applied in small villages and rural areas of our countries.
  • Professionals in wastewater management and waste have the responsability to develope sustainable sanitation projects.
  • The broad technologies about decentralized and onsite wastewater systems have to be appropriately covered in university engineering curricula, because public health officials, engineers, regulators, system designers, inspectors, and developers often possess only limited knowledge about these.

Recommendations:

To achieve a sustainable wastewater management, centralized, decentralized and onsite systems have to fulfill principles of reduction, reuse and recycle of water and wastewater during each step of treatment.




Composting toilets and processes

Diagram of a typical composting toilet process


Properties of the two SIRDO systems

Dry SIRDOWet SIRDO
  • Waterless sanitation
  • Aerobic decomposition of human manure
  • Organic matter is added in the composting toilet
  • Produce a biofertilizer free of pathogens
  • No use of water for sewage
  • Organic and fecal matter will be aerobically decomposed even when water is used for the toilets as the black water sediments (about 1 month) until the water is evaporated, the sludge is used as inoculum for composting.
  • Grey water is collected seperately, it can be easily biologically treated by a reed bed filter (natural wastewater treatment) and reused for irrigation or flushing toilets.


As in the composting toilet there is too much liquid, sawdust should be added or you separate the urine by no-mix toilets (see pictures below).

No-mix-toilet  No-mix-toilet

No-mix-toilet (BB Innovation, Sweden)


Joint recycling 

The concept of joint recycling
of human excreta and kitchen
refuse

 

Two vault system  Joint recycling


Composting process

Diagram of typical composting processes

Thermal deathpoints of pathogens and parasites:

OrganismsTemperature [°C]Time in minutes
Salmonella typhosa55 - 6030
Salmonella spp.5660
Shigella spp.5560
Escherichia coli5515 - 20
Streptococcus pyogenes5410
Mycobacterium diphteriae5545
Brucella abortus or suis613
Endamoeba histolytica (cysts)55 
Taenia saginata55 - 605
Trichnella spiralis62 - 65 
Necator americanus4550
Ascaris lumbricoides (eggs)6015 - 20
Source: Gulueke 1977


Differences between mature and raw compost:

Mature compostRaw compost
Nitrogen as nitrate ionNitrogen as ammonium ion
Sulphur as sulphate ionSulphur still in part as sulphide ion
Lower oxygen demandHigher oxygen demand
No danger of putrefactionDanger of putrefaction
Nutrient elements are in part available to plantsNutrient elements not available
Higher concentrations of vitamins and antibioticaLower concentrations of vitamins and antibiotica
Higher concentrations of soil bacteria, fungi, which are decomposed, easily degradable substancesHigher concentrations of bacteria and fungi, which decompose organic materials
Mineralizaion is about 50%High proportion of organic substances not mineralized
Higher water retention abilityLower water retention ability
Clay-humus complexes are builtNo clay-humus complexes generated
Compatible with plantsNot compatible with plants


Increase of soil quality by the use of compost:

Compost may be used on land for the following purposes: agriculture, horticulture, home gardening, vegetable gardening, viticulture, landscaping, landfill, forestry or commercial farming. It is usually applied as mulch, soil conditioner or fertilizer for many of these applications.

Fate of compost in the soil

 
Soil structure and quality:
Soil quality Soil quality
 
Physical effects of the addition of compost to clay or sandy soils:

Sandy soil + compostClay soil + compost
Water content is increasedAeration of soil increased
Water retention is increasedPermeability of soil to water increased
Aggregation of soil particles is enhancedPotential crusting of soil surface is decreased
Erosion is reducedCompaction is reduced

 

Sanitary aspects of compost toilets

Sanitation alternatives: classification of methods

  Wet systemsDry systems
On site Pour flush pit latrines
Septic tanks and soakaways
Other pit latrines
Compost latrines
Off site Sewerage
Overhung latrines
Bucket latrines
Vault latrines


When handling composted waste,
  • use rubber (nonpermeable) gloves
  • wash your hands thoroughly afterwards
  • keep tools used for working with the contents of composter in a contained and out-of-the-way place.

Possible ways of infection:



Consequences because of the lack of sanitation

DiseasePeople infectedDeaths per year
CholeraMore than 300,000More than 3,000
Diarrhoeal diseases700 million or more infected each yearMore than 5 million
Roundworm800 - 1,000 million20,000
Bilharzia200 millionover 200,000
Filariasis90 million---


But still there has to be different solutions for different situations as ...

Different situations of defecation Some people ...but others ...
defecate in the openprefer a sheltered place
defecate in or near wateruse a dry place
defecate in or near houseget right away of the house
squatsit
defecate at sunrise and sunsetrelieve themselves whenever the need arises
use water for anal cleaninguse paper, leaves, sticks, stones, corncobs etc.

Apart from personal preferences, some customs are controlled by religious or social taboos such as:
  • not being seen defecating or even going to a latrine;
  • the direction faced when defecating;
  • strict separation of men and women;
  • ritual bathing before or after defecation;
  • ne defecation near a cemetery or near a sacred place (such as a rock or old tree); and
  • feces can't be handled, even when decomposed.

Wagner and Lanoix criteria for satisfactory excreta disposal:
  • no surface soil contamination
  • no contamination of springs or wells
  • no contamination of surface water
  • no acces to flies or animals
  • minimum handling of fresh excreta
  • freedom from smells and unsightly conditions
  • simple and inexpensive in construction and operation

Marais criteria for satisfactory sanitation:
  • should be cheap
  • should not be communal
  • uses little or no water
  • operates despite misuse
  • requires little supervision
  • does not use soakaways
  • disposes of all wastewater
  • treats wastewater with little danger to users
  • uses no mechanical equipment
 


back



http://www.wifu.org/    last change: Mar 06, 2001      ifu suderburg logo "sophisticated fish" © 2000 Zahra Khojasteh
Comments please to webmaster@wifu.org  
hosted by ifu service center suderburg, at the University of Applied Sciences NON, Dept. Suderburg